Results 31 to 39 of 39
			
		Thread: Abu Dhabi Grand Prix 2011
- 
	15th November 2011, 17:52 #31Senior Member
			
			
- Join Date
 - Dec 2007
 - Posts
 - 1,461
 - Like
 - 109
 - Liked 47 Times in 35 Posts
 
after the first left hand bend,Vettel went completely over the ridge on the right of the track,and actually straddled the ridge,with his right hand tyres .No one else did,they rode up onto the ridge,but no one else went over it,as vettel did, immediately he rejoined the track for the next left,then felt the tyre let him down,and spun off .
 - 
	15th November 2011, 18:20 #32Senior Member
			
			
- Join Date
 - Sep 2005
 - Posts
 - 2,607
 - Like
 - 28
 - Liked 186 Times in 146 Posts
 
After watching the replay from the rear angle, I like the theory that the tyre got pulled off the rim coming back across the outside edge of the kerb (with the pressure still low).
 - 
	17th November 2011, 15:40 #33Senior Member
			
			
- Join Date
 - Apr 2002
 - Posts
 - 15,233
 - Like
 - 0
 - Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
 
This from Paul Hembury."We did the investigation with Red Bull and that's what we both concluded. There's no sign of any tyre failure other than something has clearly created a big hole in it."
Pirelli's Paul Hembery says they will never know what caused Vettel's puncture - F1 news - AUTOSPORT.com
So, it wasn't Pirelli's fault it failed and it's unlikely it was debris.
I know Hembury says there are 100's of potential causes but if you discount the Tyre failing and debris, it leaves just a few alternatives:
1. Something RBR did caused the failure
2. How the car took the curbs caused the failure
3. Sabotage
Pretty unlikely to be number 3 (although Pauls wording doesn't exclude this) and Seb didn't look like he was overly lairy in the first corner, although he might have caught a curb wrong. We will never know for sure but my guess it may be number 1.
 - 
	17th November 2011, 16:13 #34Senior Member
			
			
- Join Date
 - Jul 2006
 - Location
 - Estonia
 - Posts
 - 6,744
 - Like
 - 145
 - Liked 209 Times in 165 Posts
 
Considering, how fond can people be about conspiracy theories, this case would simply make a brilliant plot for such story.
 Originally Posted by Knock-on
					
				
 If this was something that decided the championship, we would surely have some theories flying around.
"Oh there was a random cut in the tyre and no-one understands, how this was possible." Khmm...
 :
						
 - 
	17th November 2011, 16:19 #35Senior Member
			
			
- Join Date
 - Mar 2002
 - Posts
 - 6,410
 - Like
 - 0
 - Liked 32 Times in 32 Posts
 
Doesn't really tell the whole story:
 Originally Posted by Matthew
					
				
Alonso being Alonso with his Bulldog spirit
Webber compromised into a 3 stopper and provided overtaking even if the end result would be fallible
FI's split tyre strategyThe world according to Taki Inoue: https://mobile.twitter.com/takiinoue/st ... 7249326080
 - 
	17th November 2011, 16:50 #36Senior Member
			
			
- Join Date
 - Aug 2004
 - Location
 - Kent, near Brands Hatch
 - Posts
 - 6,539
 - Like
 - 0
 - Liked 3 Times in 3 Posts
 
You can see this on the F1 Forum on iPlayer, it's at 52mins and 54secs ish......
 Originally Posted by SGWilko
					
				Opinions are like ar5eholes, everyone has one.
 - 
	20th November 2011, 02:57 #37
I've now read that RBR possibly underinflated Seb's rear tires in order to give him more traction while leaving the line (Just like is done in drag racing). That might actually explain his great get-a-ways all season. The tires that he then get's after the first pitstop are then inflated more.
Anyway, that might have cost him the race, when you consider the massive side load and heavily fueled car into the first couple of cornersForm is Temporary, Class is Permanent
 - 
	20th November 2011, 21:57 #38Senior Member
			
			
- Join Date
 - Apr 2002
 - Posts
 - 15,233
 - Like
 - 0
 - Liked 0 Times in 0 Posts
 
I've also had another idea. What if Red Bull are using more of an air mix to inflate the tyres. This would mean that there is lower pressure (more grip) off the line but when the tyres get up to temp, they'll be up to full pressure. Only problem is that it wasn't up to pressure by the corner and popped the bead.
Just a theory but could explain it.
 - 
	26th November 2011, 17:01 #39Senior Member
			
			
- Join Date
 - Mar 2002
 - Posts
 - 6,410
 - Like
 - 0
 - Liked 32 Times in 32 Posts
 
According undisclosed RBR sources Autosport magazine reported that RBR's exhaust system - which also heats up the hub caused the tyre to fail. A plume of smoke was visible just before the start coming from the rear of Vettel's car.
The world according to Taki Inoue: https://mobile.twitter.com/takiinoue/st ... 7249326080
 


					
					
					
						
  Reply With Quote
			
		
			
						
					
						
			
The problem is that they don't make the decision soon enough, or even have it in the plan before the race. The guy behind who's just come out on fresh tyres & is 2 seconds a lap faster needs the call...
2025 Race 20 - Mexico