Results 281 to 290 of 319
Thread: Craig Breen
-
2nd February 2024, 10:40 #281
- Join Date
- Jan 2001
- Location
- Athens Greece
- Posts
- 472
- Like
- 1
- Liked 98 Times in 52 Posts
- Likes: bluuford (6th February 2024),Eli (2nd February 2024),WRC1 (2nd February 2024)
-
5th February 2024, 09:27 #282
- Join Date
- Mar 2010
- Location
- England
- Posts
- 18,898
- Like
- 3,429
- Liked 9,358 Times in 4,972 Posts
Its strange we still havent had any more details of the accident from the team or the cause of death. You'd think after a WRC fatality it would get a full investigation or enquiry and would've revealed everything and any lessons to be learned.
-
5th February 2024, 09:34 #283
- Likes: becher (5th February 2024),cali (7th February 2024),Corcaíoch (5th February 2024),DoN_cz (5th February 2024),EstWRC (5th February 2024),Jewy46 (6th February 2024),kure91 (8th February 2024),logwrc (5th February 2024),Mirek (5th February 2024),PLuto (5th February 2024),satnav (6th February 2024),steve.mandzij (7th February 2024),TWRC (6th February 2024),TypeR (5th February 2024),WRC1 (5th February 2024)
-
5th February 2024, 10:33 #284
- Join Date
- Aug 2006
- Posts
- 1,822
- Like
- 1,474
- Liked 1,835 Times in 710 Posts
- Likes: Eli (5th February 2024)
-
5th February 2024, 12:47 #285
- Join Date
- Mar 2010
- Location
- England
- Posts
- 18,898
- Like
- 3,429
- Liked 9,358 Times in 4,972 Posts
This was the last we were told in April 2023:
"Hyundai Motorsport and the FIA are working together to review all aspects of the incident."
But no result of this review have been published.
If it was found to be a freak accident and nothing can be done to avoid a similar one then they should just confirm this.
-
5th February 2024, 14:52 #286
- Join Date
- Jan 2018
- Location
- GB, Manchester
- Posts
- 2,266
- Like
- 498
- Liked 2,129 Times in 924 Posts
Every sensible person puts 1+1 together, no extra detailed explanation needed.
You didn't copy the whole section..
In April Abiteboul said:
“Road conditions were slippery and the car slid off the road at a relatively low speed and made contact with a wooden fence. A post from this fence intruded into the cabin through the driver’s side window.
As far as can be ascertained, there was no issue with any element of the car, the tires or the safety equipment.''Last edited by TypeR; 5th February 2024 at 14:56.
- Likes: becher (5th February 2024),WRC1 (5th February 2024)
-
6th February 2024, 08:08 #287
- Join Date
- Aug 2011
- Posts
- 1,955
- Like
- 1
- Liked 1,133 Times in 607 Posts
there clearly are some serious issues with the tubular chassis concerning the puncturing of objects into the cockpit.
they put foam everywhere, but there is nothing made of solid metal anymore to stop things getting in.
but what happened to breen was a freak accident. you can never make a rally car completely impervious.
-
6th February 2024, 17:08 #288
- Join Date
- Jun 2007
- Location
- Prague / Eastern Bohemia
- Posts
- 22,505
- Like
- 7,834
- Liked 11,152 Times in 4,427 Posts
The issue is that penetration of a rally/race car by an object with small cross section is virtually impossible to prevent because the kinetic energy of the car is way too much for creating any sort of working protection. Moreover in most cases the objects penetrates the cockpit through the windshield or side windows. Even if you put a bullet proof glass (which is super heavy) it will not be enough to prevent penetration by something like a steel pipe at higher speeds. It's not an issue of a tube frame.
Just to illustrate what I am talking about. The WRC car with the crew weights around 1400 kg. If it is going 100 km/h it has a kinetic energy equivalent to a shot from this.
If you have an object with a small cross-section it will penetrate whatever you can build into a car. I remember I saw a railguard penetrating an engine block of a BMW X5 in a Kubica-style accident.Stupid is as stupid does. Forrest Gump
- Likes: becher (6th February 2024)
-
6th February 2024, 17:32 #289
- Join Date
- Mar 2010
- Location
- England
- Posts
- 18,898
- Like
- 3,429
- Liked 9,358 Times in 4,972 Posts
Breen's off was officially classsed as low speed. And the impact was side-on as the post went into the side window. None of this impact was anything like a shot from a howitzer.
Freak accident or not, I'd like to see it confirmed how the FIA saw it, and them clarify nothing can be done to prevent such a thing happening again.
-
6th February 2024, 17:56 #290
- Join Date
- Jun 2007
- Location
- Prague / Eastern Bohemia
- Posts
- 22,505
- Like
- 7,834
- Liked 11,152 Times in 4,427 Posts
Exactly. A shot from a pistol is 500J, that is 2000x less and an equivalent of a car moving by a speed of 2 km/h but you still need 20 mm thick glass to stop it. That is about 25 kg for a side window (glass alone, not a frame to hold it during a crash). For sure the bullet has a smaller cross section than a pole so the penetration ability will be lesser but for an idea about what energies we are talking about it is a good comparison I think.
Last edited by Mirek; 6th February 2024 at 18:02.
Stupid is as stupid does. Forrest Gump
strong performance.
WRC2 news & rumors 2024