Page 83 of 141 FirstFirst ... 3373818283848593133 ... LastLast
Results 821 to 830 of 1401
  1. #821
    Senior Member Fast Eddie WRC's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    England
    Posts
    18,869
    Like
    3,427
    Liked 9,346 Times in 4,964 Posts
    Swapping batteries is like cheating if they're trying to promote this tech for the public. This would just show people that battery range is still a problem and put them off switching to electric. Everyone knows EVs works and the acceleration is great but it's the battery range that needs proving.

  2. #822
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    Estonia
    Posts
    3,749
    Like
    471
    Liked 1,779 Times in 421 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Mk2 RS2000 View Post
    Hydrogen cell technology overcomes battery size, power & storage issues
    WRC has been always something where new technologies have been tested. Battery technology is old technology and and does not have sustainable future in current format (I say it as a part time geologist - my PhD study was on the borderline of ecology and geology). If we take all known geological resources, we can change all the cars to battery technology, but there are no more resources to replace all those batteries in the future, unless some new technology will be invented.

    One of the most important law I studied at school was the law that was telling "the more weight you carry, the more energy you need." So, for me it is very strange that so far this law is ignored. We carry hybrid unit, we carry batteries and in total, depends on the car, proper Tesla battery weight is between 400-500 kg. and now imagine, millions of cars are carrying this extra weight.. does not sound very sustainable?
    MK2 is right, we need concentrated energy. Hydrogen is on of them Currently Toyota Mirai fuel tank weight is around 80 kg, fuel capacity is around 5 kg, so, the weight in car is 85 kg. And you can cover approximately 500 km with this tank. For me, this is the way to develop. Hydrogen can be produced when the energy is cheap (too much wind or sun energy, high peaks of nuclear energy production and low consumption at the same time). So, we don't need to carry "power station" in each car, energy can be produced in centralized locations and we use only concentrated fuel.
    At the same time it is hard to achieve, car manufacturers have made their investments in electric cars. Normal investment cycle is 30 years, 10 years you develop and spend money, next 10 years you earn back your investment, and final 10 years you earn profit.

    WRC does not need to follow it, we can be innovative for once and not use 100+ years old technology and say it is new
    Colins Crest = Möldri Mätas

  3. Likes: 240RS (7th July 2022),AMSS (7th July 2022),AnttiL (7th July 2022),Augury (9th July 2022),cali (7th July 2022),dimviii (7th July 2022),EstWRC (7th July 2022),flat_right (7th July 2022),J4MIE (7th July 2022),Jewy46 (7th July 2022),lancia037 (8th July 2022),sindroms (7th July 2022),Sulland (19th July 2022),TWRC (8th July 2022),TypeR (7th July 2022),wyler (11th July 2022)
  4. #823
    Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Posts
    30
    Like
    49
    Liked 8 Times in 6 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by bluuford View Post
    WRC has been always something where new technologies have been tested. Battery technology is old technology and and does not have sustainable future in current format (I say it as a part time geologist - my PhD study was on the borderline of ecology and geology). If we take all known geological resources, we can change all the cars to battery technology, but there are no more resources to replace all those batteries in the future, unless some new technology will be invented.

    One of the most important law I studied at school was the law that was telling "the more weight you carry, the more energy you need." So, for me it is very strange that so far this law is ignored. We carry hybrid unit, we carry batteries and in total, depends on the car, proper Tesla battery weight is between 400-500 kg. and now imagine, millions of cars are carrying this extra weight.. does not sound very sustainable?
    MK2 is right, we need concentrated energy. Hydrogen is on of them Currently Toyota Mirai fuel tank weight is around 80 kg, fuel capacity is around 5 kg, so, the weight in car is 85 kg. And you can cover approximately 500 km with this tank. For me, this is the way to develop. Hydrogen can be produced when the energy is cheap (too much wind or sun energy, high peaks of nuclear energy production and low consumption at the same time). So, we don't need to carry "power station" in each car, energy can be produced in centralized locations and we use only concentrated fuel.
    At the same time it is hard to achieve, car manufacturers have made their investments in electric cars. Normal investment cycle is 30 years, 10 years you develop and spend money, next 10 years you earn back your investment, and final 10 years you earn profit.

    WRC does not need to follow it, we can be innovative for once and not use 100+ years old technology and say it is new
    Yes, battery technology is old technology, but it is nowhere near developed to its full potential whereas ICE technology has reached 99,9% of it's possibilities. Battery tech is already showing promising solutions and I am sure as material technology is also helping bring innovative solutions we will see much more energy dense packs in the future. Car industry "big money" has supported battery tech far too short period to call it a dead end. Hydrogen fuel cell cars are also in principle electric cars which carry power plant with them to make electricity from H2 to store it shortly in battery, then use it with electric motor. That's a big issue with H2 in transportation, it has a lot of losses of energy compared to only battery powered cars and it makes cars more complicated.

  5. Likes: AnttiL (7th July 2022)
  6. #824
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Exmuhle.....
    Posts
    5,296
    Like
    2,614
    Liked 1,251 Times in 680 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by bluuford View Post
    WRC does not need to follow it, we can be innovative for once and not use 100+ years old technology and say it is new
    Yes, WRC hasn't been innovative for a long time; it tends to follow what other series do with technology. One of the reasons it can't attract manufacturers......who will go elsewhere to demonstrate new technology.

    Is there a better sound than that of Porsche engined Flat-6 ???

  7. Likes: cali (7th July 2022)
  8. #825
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    Estonia
    Posts
    3,749
    Like
    471
    Liked 1,779 Times in 421 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Tanelv View Post
    Yes, battery technology is old technology, but it is nowhere near developed to its full potential whereas ICE technology has reached 99,9% of it's possibilities. Battery tech is already showing promising solutions and I am sure as material technology is also helping bring innovative solutions we will see much more energy dense packs in the future. Car industry "big money" has supported battery tech far too short period to call it a dead end. Hydrogen fuel cell cars are also in principle electric cars which carry power plant with them to make electricity from H2 to store it shortly in battery, then use it with electric motor. That's a big issue with H2 in transportation, it has a lot of losses of energy compared to only battery powered cars and it makes cars more complicated.
    Yes I know
    To me the next evolution would be proper solution to use H2 directly (basically like H2 powered ICE, to say it in a very simple manner). That would be proper innovation for me, lets see, I am not an engine engineer, so far I stick to weather, I know this field slightly better.

    But I think we have gone too far from news in this topic
    Colins Crest = Möldri Mätas

  9. Likes: Augury (9th July 2022),cali (7th July 2022),WRC1 (7th July 2022)
  10. #826
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2000
    Posts
    11,747
    Like
    450
    Liked 576 Times in 209 Posts
    I work in the UK gas industry and there is a lot of development towards using hydrogen in the network so it could be within a few years a lot more availability of hydrogen across the country.

    We currently have two hydrogen cars at our office, but you have to remember the nearest filling point from here is approx 70km away….
    If the world didn't suck, we'd all fall off!

  11. Likes: AnttiL (7th July 2022),cali (7th July 2022)
  12. #827
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2014
    Location
    Timaru NZ
    Posts
    443
    Like
    107
    Liked 306 Times in 158 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Tanelv View Post
    Yes, battery technology is old technology, but it is nowhere near developed to its full potential whereas ICE technology has reached 99,9% of it's possibilities. Battery tech is already showing promising solutions and I am sure as material technology is also helping bring innovative solutions we will see much more energy dense packs in the future. Car industry "big money" has supported battery tech far too short period to call it a dead end. Hydrogen fuel cell cars are also in principle electric cars which carry power plant with them to make electricity from H2 to store it shortly in battery, then use it with electric motor. That's a big issue with H2 in transportation, it has a lot of losses of energy compared to only battery powered cars and it makes cars more complicated.
    Take the time to check out the developments in the heavy vehicle industry. For example trucking and fork lifts using electric motors. Powered by hydrogen cells now becoming well developed in Asia and the USA There are a lot of things happening outside of Europe
    Things happen for reasons, not excuses.

  13. Likes: cali (9th July 2022)
  14. #828
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Posts
    287
    Like
    46
    Liked 65 Times in 46 Posts
    The happiest people with electric vehicles in my assessment have been used Nissan Leaf owners who live outside small towns (20 to 30 km commute distance drive). Have their own home solar systems to charge the Nissans with.
    The 2nd gen Toyota Mirai weighs 1920-1950kg an increase of up to 100kg over the first gen Mirai. The 2nd gen Mirai is heavier than the current edition standard range Tesla Model 3.(1835kg)

    I have heard of people driving Teslas into the ground, that these people went back to driving gasoline/ petrol cars.
    Any shift to new tech will involve winners and losers.

    Ballard and fuel cell buses, Scotland. https://youtu.be/91ZCI9f_nmI

    Hopefully Airpod can get their act together (compressed air short distance small vehicle)

    The people that are 70km from the hydrogen refuel, might look (if rules allow) to get a few hydrogen cylinders like an oxy-acetylene torch cylinder setup, that can give them local partial hydrogen vehicle refuelling.

  15. #829
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2018
    Location
    GB, Manchester
    Posts
    2,244
    Like
    498
    Liked 2,121 Times in 918 Posts
    Upgrades for Toyota:
    https://dirtfish.com/rally/wrc/the-u...-see-in-tartu/

    “Fowler: So yeah, a more powerful engine is coming.”
    Hyundai..

  16. Likes: Eli (10th July 2022),Ha3aP (10th July 2022)
  17. #830
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Posts
    5,802
    Like
    337
    Liked 3,791 Times in 1,979 Posts
    Wasn't the petrol engine supposed to be somehow "frozen" since mid-last year? Guess not everything is frozen.

    I'd say MSport should be more concerned since even Fowler says this is a reaction to some Hyundai upgrades. Let's hope MSport doesn't start lagging too fast. (At least not before we see more starts with performing drivers)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •