Page 666 of 747 FirstFirst ... 166566616656664665666667668676716 ... LastLast
Results 6,651 to 6,660 of 7463
  1. #6651
    Senior Member Fast Eddie WRC's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    England
    Posts
    18,784
    Like
    3,417
    Liked 9,313 Times in 4,939 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Sulland View Post
    Has the Polo gotten any newer jokers or is this list complete?
    https://autorally.lv/files/r198/R5-J...-VW%20Polo.pdf

    I must say I am impressed that the Polo still seems to be one of the top two RC2 cars, long after VW left the sport.
    The Polo still is the most stable and well balanced Rally2/R5 car, and performs well on all sufaces.

    I am guessing the new Fabia will use lessons identified from the Polo to increase VAGs grip on the class.
    In the MEM video above, they say how well-engineered the Polo R5 is (much being based on the Polo WRC) and the really high quality of its components (compared to their previous i20).

  2. #6652
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Belgium
    Posts
    3,585
    Like
    1,913
    Liked 3,476 Times in 1,016 Posts
    The Polo R5 was according to many engineers/mechanics a bit like a "small WRC", it's a fantastic car, there's a lot to play with, but it has to be set up properly. Not everyone can jump in and be fast with it, while the Fabia has the reputation of being a much easier car to drive. Seeing the numbers it's clear which car is most successful. The Fabia winning many national events and championships all around the world. At Skoda Motorsport, it's more about having a profitable business with many customers rather than having a works team winning championships. It would make sense to stick with their philosophy and build another "user-friendly" car where it's easier for customers to extract the potential of the car.

    BTW as the rumors say, Skoda's going to spend a whole week doing development tests in the Ypres region. They're really taking it everywhere.

  3. Likes: Jarek Z (20th February 2022),pantealex (20th February 2022),Sulland (20th February 2022)
  4. #6653
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2016
    Posts
    564
    Like
    0
    Liked 335 Times in 203 Posts
    I don’t have the same opinion on the Polo R5. For me, it’s a disappointment: it was VW car (big domination in WRC), the group had Skoda’s experience in R5 (and Skoda stopped their development with VW coming) and it was clearly customer-oriented as a project (except the first rally, they never had a team as Skoda had with Lappi, Tidemand, Kopecky or Rovanpera). So the goal was clearly to overtake the Fabia and to be the next big thing in this category.

    And ok, they succeeded in matching the level of the Fabia but they didn’t manage to overtake it whereas the Polo was newer. Polo has some points better (more high-performance oriented) than Fabia and the contrary is true also (Skoda probably more polyvalent and easy to use).
    And now, the Citroen is also at this level I think.
    Probably the fires (Camilli, Kajto, one guy in Portugal) didn’t help them also to promote it.

    So in the end, I would not say the Polo R5 is a failure but a disappointment, yes clearly: the ultimate proof is that the group decides to stop the evolution of the Polo and to come back to the Fabia as the main car to develop.

  5. Likes: Jarek Z (20th February 2022)
  6. #6654
    Senior Member Jarek Z's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2001
    Location
    Wroclaw
    Posts
    8,569
    Like
    4,447
    Liked 3,290 Times in 1,732 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Danny0405 View Post
    Probably the fires (Camilli, Kajto, one guy in Portugal) didn’t help them also to promote it.
    Apart from the fires

    https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-erD0PA8Hz...86225920_n.jpg

    there were also rear suspension problems, at least for Kajto, Veiby, Saba and some other drivers:

    https://static.motor.es/fotos-notici...01849670_1.jpg

    https://twitter.com/PeAChapaRacing/s...201849670.html

    http://www.kwa-kwa.pl/strona/images/...5/image008.jpg

    https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-PMLX46MYO...56041216_n.jpg

    so Polo R5 had quite a bad start which may have discouraged many customers...
    http://www.rallymadness.prv.pl - rally photos and movies!

  7. Likes: RS (21st February 2022)
  8. #6655
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2016
    Posts
    564
    Like
    0
    Liked 335 Times in 203 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Jarek Z View Post
    Apart from the fires

    https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-erD0PA8Hz...86225920_n.jpg

    there were also rear suspension problems, at least for Kajto, Veiby, Saba and some other drivers:

    https://static.motor.es/fotos-notici...01849670_1.jpg

    https://twitter.com/PeAChapaRacing/s...201849670.html

    http://www.kwa-kwa.pl/strona/images/...5/image008.jpg

    https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-PMLX46MYO...56041216_n.jpg

    so Polo R5 had quite a bad start which may have discouraged many customers...
    Ok, I made a confusion (Kajto had a fire but it was not a VW, it was Veiby with VW and the Portuguese guy I was thinking about was Meireles): but having two cars with a fire in the same rally (Veiby + Meireles in Portugal WRC 2019) and 3 in 2 months (including Camilli in Corsica 2019) is clearly really bad for promotion, especially when it happens in WRC with drivers in contention for class win.

    Rear suspension issues has not helped for sure.
    It’s always difficult to face a reliable car (as the Fabia is) from the beginning (neither VW, nor Citroen, Ford and Hyundai succeeds to do it and only VW and Citroen had matched it after some time).

  9. #6656
    Senior Member Jarek Z's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2001
    Location
    Wroclaw
    Posts
    8,569
    Like
    4,447
    Liked 3,290 Times in 1,732 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Danny0405 View Post
    Ok, I made a confusion (Kajto had a fire but it was not a VW, it was Veiby with VW and the Portuguese guy I was thinking about was Meireles): but having two cars with a fire in the same rally (Veiby + Meireles in Portugal WRC 2019) and 3 in 2 months (including Camilli in Corsica 2019) is clearly really bad for promotion
    There was also a Spanish driver Daniel Marban in Rally Islas Canarias in ERC:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zrhxpbymfmU
    Last edited by Jarek Z; 20th February 2022 at 21:32.
    http://www.rallymadness.prv.pl - rally photos and movies!

  10. #6657
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2000
    Posts
    8,810
    Like
    2,080
    Liked 2,241 Times in 1,199 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Danny0405 View Post
    Ok, I made a confusion (Kajto had a fire but it was not a VW, it was Veiby with VW and the Portuguese guy I was thinking about was Meireles): but having two cars with a fire in the same rally (Veiby + Meireles in Portugal WRC 2019) and 3 in 2 months (including Camilli in Corsica 2019) is clearly really bad for promotion, especially when it happens in WRC with drivers in contention for class win.

    Rear suspension issues has not helped for sure.
    It’s always difficult to face a reliable car (as the Fabia is) from the beginning (neither VW, nor Citroen, Ford and Hyundai succeeds to do it and only VW and Citroen had matched it after some time).
    When even teams who have won at WRC level struggle, it just goes to show how difficult it is to make a competitive and reliable R5 car and why proper testing is essential. The new Fiesta was not good ‘out of the box’ either despite MSport’s experience with a first generation R5.

  11. #6658
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    Belgium
    Posts
    6,488
    Like
    11
    Liked 401 Times in 267 Posts
    First day of a five day test for Skoda in Ypres Region. Today they are testing in Wervik with Jan Kopecky. They are testing latest prototype (PT3) of the new Fabia R2.

  12. Likes: Mirek (21st February 2022),RS (21st February 2022),tommeke_B (22nd February 2022)
  13. #6659
    Senior Member AnttiL's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2017
    Location
    Finland
    Posts
    9,625
    Like
    8,775
    Liked 10,522 Times in 4,616 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Danny0405 View Post
    I don’t have the same opinion on the Polo R5. For me, it’s a disappointment: it was VW car (big domination in WRC), the group had Skoda’s experience in R5 (and Skoda stopped their development with VW coming) and it was clearly customer-oriented as a project (except the first rally, they never had a team as Skoda had with Lappi, Tidemand, Kopecky or Rovanpera). So the goal was clearly to overtake the Fabia and to be the next big thing in this category.

    And ok, they succeeded in matching the level of the Fabia but they didn’t manage to overtake it whereas the Polo was newer. Polo has some points better (more high-performance oriented) than Fabia and the contrary is true also (Skoda probably more polyvalent and easy to use).
    And now, the Citroen is also at this level I think.
    Probably the fires (Camilli, Kajto, one guy in Portugal) didn’t help them also to promote it.

    So in the end, I would not say the Polo R5 is a failure but a disappointment, yes clearly: the ultimate proof is that the group decides to stop the evolution of the Polo and to come back to the Fabia as the main car to develop.
    I would disagree with you guys, I think Polo was a fast car out of the box but had some reliability issues, all of which were rectified quickly. As for posting that picture of rear axle getting loose in the tests, this is why they do tests, to see how far they can push the car before it breaks. And then fix that.

    But to me it's quite amazing that after several years of no active testing, the car can still win its class in WRC. We must remember that the factory stopped supporting the car right as it was released. There has been some updates but likely the development budget has been relatively small.


    Also remember that after Polo came the Fabia Evo, and Skoda has still a big motorsport department doing the development all the time. Citroen has also been developed constantly, and the new Hyundai had an extensive development program.

    As for being "difficult to jump into", how about Lappi and Suninen jumping into the car and winning instantly?

  14. Likes: WRC1 (21st February 2022)
  15. #6660
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2019
    Posts
    849
    Like
    227
    Liked 591 Times in 314 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by AnttiL View Post

    As for being "difficult to jump into", how about Lappi and Suninen jumping into the car and winning instantly?
    they're top-tier drivers.
    instead, i think that's very true for gentlemen and middle-tier drivers, some local drivers i chatted with -that tested and raced almost all r5- confirmed so. they said is very "professional" oriented car, that needs huge competence to get 100% potential, but also to find the soft spot around 80%-90%, while fabia on the opposite is easy to bring 80-90% with confidence.
    that's for the average customer, not a big deal for professionals stepping down from wrc, extracting easily the top performance.

    on a curious side, they reported fiesta mk2 as to have huge potential, but no feeling at all. they said you have to trust the car a lot, something they can't do, and nearly impossible for a driver doing few days in the car a year.

  16. Likes: AnttiL (21st February 2022)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •