So if a crime is committed today and nobody knows about this crime till next years july, should it not be investigated?Quote:
Originally Posted by truefan72
Printable View
So if a crime is committed today and nobody knows about this crime till next years july, should it not be investigated?Quote:
Originally Posted by truefan72
this isn't a criminal act or a matter of law.Quote:
Originally Posted by Garry Walker
Trust me, I would be happy to have Hamilton gain some extra points in the end, and imagine if massa had won the WDC, and then this comes out, so 8 months later they would overturn the championship and award it to hamilton.
Now if they are going to investigate past incidents, the first one to start with would be the disgrace at Spa last year.
Also, so what punishment should Renault 2009 receive for acions in Renault 2008. It is a mess, and I am not saying Renault are not guilty, I just don't see what difference it makes today.
What I do see is FIa/Mosley's now firmly setting their sights on Renault as they did on Maclaren. MM wants another $100 million fine, and expulsion to get one over his fota rivals and destroy the organization on the way out.
This kind of action is unprecedented in every way and smells fishy. I supposes the chief informant is Piquet, but there would have to be proper evidence to support his claim. And i am not sure that there is any. It is too far fetched of a conspiracy for it to be true.
...then again, we might be all jumping the gun and the FIA is investigating soemthing else.
After Alonso's pit stop obviously, what was so hard to plan about it?Quote:
Originally Posted by gm99
All they needed was to tell Piquet to bin it at corner x after they tell him to push (something they do often).
this is highly unlikely and I seriously doubt that there is any proof.
Now if it is proven somehow(we all knoe FIA's standards for reprimands) then piquet is just as guilty as flav and the team. If renault get banned, he should too and be stripped of a super license. Trust me, if it were true and as soon as piquet was told to do so, he had all the trump cards in his hand. If he did not comply and continued to race, then there is nothing Renault could have done without that being exposed. So he would have been in complete control of his destiny.
To me is simply looked like just another one of many, many piquet accidents.
Remember that Kimi, and Sutil crashed too. all 3 incidents looked like racing accidents and out of those 3 piquet's accident surprised me the least.
If he didn't do it he would have been shown the door. How could he have been in control of is destiny? What was there to prove that they asked him to crash if he didn't even do it?!
LOL how true.Quote:
Originally Posted by ioan
Renault tells Piquet to push harder and he promptly complies by crashing. That is more likely story to me as I am sure that it wouldn't be the first time that happened. :rolleyes:
the same evidence that showed he was ordered to crash, the fact that he did or did not do it is irrelevant to the evidence ordering him to do it. And if he didn't and had further instructions or dubious communications, then hes treasure chest of evidence would only have grown to his advantage.Quote:
Originally Posted by ioan
All on all, I think this is highly implausible anyway and maybe they are investigating something else.
But TBH I think they should just leave 2008 alone and move forward.
The way he binned it was very strange and it was questioned back then.
Also he had a spin earlier (during the formation lap)that looked like a copy of the real one, just that he controlled perfectly to the extent that he didn't even lose his place on the grid.
Definite it should be investigated and especially now when Renault kicked Piquet. Because I don’t think every one tell the truth in that case. And I hope and believe that it’s not Alonso who is the liar.Quote:
Originally Posted by Garry Walker
FIA should investigate this as soon and as quickly as it is possible..
The FIA has been investigating this ever since it happened, now it's just the moment when they found something good enough so they leaked a bit of info to the press.Quote:
Originally Posted by jas123f1