The rev limitation rules helped them out as they were unable to produce a reliable engine that could rev over 20000 rpm.Quote:
Originally Posted by jens
Printable View
The rev limitation rules helped them out as they were unable to produce a reliable engine that could rev over 20000 rpm.Quote:
Originally Posted by jens
I dont remeber too many Mercedes engines blowing up in 06.Quote:
Originally Posted by ioan
Anyway, if RBR want the Mercedes engines next year they need dispensation from the FIA and it seems like they dont want the whole grid to be powered by just one or 2 makes.
But strange enough they were not as fast as the others either.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sleeper
That wasnt down to the engine though, the McLaren just wasnt a great car that year, too much understeer for its drivers.Quote:
Originally Posted by ioan
I believe that their engine was not up there in terms of power with the other engines that were able to safely rev over 20K rpm, they most probably designed an engine that produced peak power at lower revs. Once everyone was restricted to 19K rpm the Mercedes was starting to be equal to the Ferrari and BMW engines and when the revs were restricted to 18K rpm Mercedes reaped the rewards for having an engine that was designed to produce top power around 18K rpm while the other engines were designed with over 20K rpm in mind.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sleeper
This certainly isn't excusing Renault who had this winter at disposal to improve their engine and they are still not up there.
Errr, you started off talking about reliability, which was ery good as far as I can remember, and as I remember it the Mercedes was the second engine to hit 20 000rpm after the Cosworth. The fact that Kimi finished an unchallenged 2nd at Monza (without looking like he was too bothered about catching Michael) suggests that there was little wrong with that engine in terms of outright power.Quote:
Originally Posted by ioan
And me thinking the firsts one was BMW.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sleeper
Anyway how many seconds before the Mercedes thing exploded after reaching the 20K rpms while BMW was hitting 21K? Not too many.
McLaren's chassis has used to be very good on so-called mechanical grip circuits in recent years, in 2006 it was evidenced by the fact that they were fast at Melbourne, Monaco, Montreal, Hungaroring and Monza.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sleeper
Sooner or later all F1 teams are going to be Mercedes-Benz sponsored by santander! ;)
You can make a fast engine reliable by development but it's very hard to make a slow reliable engine into a fast relaible engine.Quote:
Originally Posted by jens
I remember when Kimi moved thinking "too soon Kimi". He went through the pain barrier but then the engine sterted to come good. Bet he's wondering the same even though he lucked into the WDC a bit by the Alonso / Lewis war :)
Totally agree. The rules were there for everyone and yet Renault were allowed special dispensation to improve their engine. The fact is that the engine is as good as the Ferrari or Mercedes unit for pace is one thing but they can still develop the engine with relaibility modifications which is what's hurting them.Quote:
Originally Posted by ioan
On it's day, the Renault is as good as anyone but it's reliability that's killed RBR championship.